Graduated seniors Loryn DeFalco and Jessika Jaime joined current seniors Maddie McMahon, Patricia Kalesse, Kelly Rasulo & Lauren Sabihon and junior Isabelle DeChiaro in making the list. DeFalco, McMahon, Rasulo and Sabihon all received honors for the second time in their collegiate careers, with each of them also doing so in 2017.

All seven of this year's recipients held a term GPA of 3.5 or better during the 2018-19 academic year. They all each were placed on both the MAAC All-Academic Team and the MAAC Academic Honor Roll. Overall, Siena Softball posted a 3.28 cumulative GPA for the Spring 2019 semester and currently holds a 3.33 overall GPA.

The selected Saints joined over 8,000 student-athletes that were named 2019 Easton/NFCA All-America Scholar-Athletes, a record number for the organization. This included 1,769 within NCAA Division 1 and 69 from Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference Schools.